20 comments

Kimberly Wagner

Whoa--Not the "S" Word!

Posted on 05.26.09 by Kimberly Wagner | Twitter: @KimberlyWagner7
Topics: Marriage

Laura Doyle is a self-proclaimed feminist, but interestingly, after years of marital struggle, she tried an experiment that brought greater intimacy and fulfillment to her marriage. The promotional page of her book states, "The underlying principle of The Surrendered Wife is simple: The control women wield at work and with children must be left at the front door of any marriage.”* Although Doyle may be unaware of it, what she discovered is not a new solution to an age-old problem but is simply the application of Scripture's principle of submission.

Do you cringe when you hear the "S" word? Do thoughts of wimpy women held captive under a domineering husband's authoritarian rule come to mind? Sadly, submission is greatly misunderstood and often misapplied. Before we examine submission, let's establish what it is not.

Submission is not:
  • Offering blind obedience to authority.
  • Enabling totalitarian dictatorship.
  • Suffering abusive treatment silently.
  • Living as a doormat.

Submission is:
  • Recognizing that God is our authority.
  • Willingly surrendering our rights to Him as our Ruler.
  • Setting aside our will for His will.
  • Living in the freedom that comes from obedience.

In the New Testament, the word translated "submit" is a military term meaning "to arrange in military fashion under a commander." Viewing submission from this perspective, we wouldn't argue over the need for one to fill the "commander" role in military combat. Imagine the chaos if there was no recognized "leader!"

Submission occurs even within the Godhead. Each member of the Trinity is equal in essence, worth, and value. But in addition to this equality, there is also a difference in role and function. The Son submits to the Father's will and plan (see John 5:30, 6:38), yet submitting does not make Him any less God. It doesn't demean His worth in any measure. But in a world that promotes independence, self-esteem, and "looking out for number one," submission is derided as weakness.

Ephesians 5 gives a clear description of the authority structure for the home. The wife demonstrates her submission to the Lord by recognizing and submitting to her husband as the spiritual head of the home. The relationship between the Church's position of submission to Christ is used as a parallel for the wife's relationship with her husband. Although this passage is totally counter-cultural and may at first seem to place the woman in a subservient role, in actuality she is being given the highest honor by comparing her to the Church—Christ's treasured possession. The more difficult task actually falls upon the husband, who is required to love his wife as Christ loved the Church.

Without the humility of Christ, submission is impossible. As we grow in Him and begin to follow His example, we'll find joy in our submission to Him and our understanding of submission will deepen.

Look back at my list of what "Submission Is" and what "Submission is Not," and let me know if you've incorrectly viewed submission.

 *Laura Doyle, The Surrendered Wife (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1999), Promotional Back Cover.

Comments

  1. Thank you for this post, this message needs to be "preached" loud and clear to all generations of women. Although not always successful in submitting, I have found true freedom in obediance to God and my husband. We don't always get it right, but after 24 years of marriage I am trusting God that we are models of what it looks like to complement one another.
    www.jodylynne.blogspot.com
    posted by Jody
    on Tuesday, May 26, 2009 at 9:33 am
  2. I have been married for almost 43 years and of those years, 35 of them were living in the "not" category. I was angry and frustrated and felt defeated, yet when I finally gave my marriage to the Lord, He began teaching me the truth about submission. He convinced me that all along I was fighting against what I wanted the most, a loving husband, and a joyfilled marriage. Thank God, my husband wouldn't let me "emasculate" him by being angry and trying to take control when it was never mine to have in the first place. I now sigh in relief that I am not responsible for his role, I am only responsible for mine. I love the word submission. I am now free to be the loving and supportive
    "helper" God designed for me to be. There are two words that God has used to help me more than any others. Respect: it builds our men up for their leadership role; And Submission: which gives them the opportunity to lead. When I learned how to show respect to him and for his position as my "head", and I stepped under him in submission, he blossomed. These are the best years of our marriage. Thank you, Roh, for all you do to help us in God's design for us.
    posted by Starr
    on Tuesday, May 26, 2009 at 10:01 am
  3. Thank you, Kimberly! Yes, by His grace, I believe I view submission correctly now (great definition you gave). For many years, though, I viewed it incorrectly. I am thankful that the Lord brought good teaching into my life and gave me a heart to understand it. He has transformed my marriage as both my husband and I have come into a Biblical understanding of it -- it is very sweet!
    I still must guard my heart to be sure I'm "properly arranged" in all areas of my life, as it pertains to submission to God-ordained authority. I know His divine authority is for our good, and even when we don't understand everything, He is often protecting us as we submit.
    In His love,
    posted by Leslie S.
    on Tuesday, May 26, 2009 at 4:02 pm
  4. I used to get stiff when I heard the word "submission"; it has been a hard thing for me to learn. I just didn't like it. THankfully, because of God's mercy and grace in my life, I can now appreciate my place of submission to God and to my husband. I'm so thankful for Nancy's teaching on submission and for what I've learned from other women God has put into my life. One of the points that has helped me the most is that I submit "as to the Lord". I think I've had growth in this area, but I know I have so much more room to grow. I have, at times, submitted outwardly, but in my heart I was very resistant--that isn't submission at all. I think a good indicator of whether or not I'm doing well in this area of submission would be to ask my husband if he senses a submissive spirit from me.
    posted by Vivian
    on Tuesday, May 26, 2009 at 7:19 pm
  5. Thank you for posting this! This is something that I have been struggling with - control. I have such a hard time submitting my control over to God. I seem to have this mindset of needing to handle things my way, in my time. However, things don't seem to work out quite so well when I try to actually carry that out!

    The parallel between Christ and the church and the wife and the husband relationship is a beautiful one... yet it is sad to see that I cringe at submitting everything completely over to God. He has been bringing to my attention lately how hard of a time I am going to have submitting to my husband in the future if I have such a hard time submitting even small things over to God now (and even others when it is necessary).

    Thank you for posting this. It goes right along with what God has been teaching me!
    www.agirlsjourneywithGod.blogspot.com
    posted by Molly
    on Tuesday, May 26, 2009 at 10:42 pm
  6. I have found the more I put into practice the decision to submit, no matter if it's with my husband or with some other authority or God, the easier it is the next time. It is the same with saying "no" to a repeated temptation. The 1st time saying no is the hardest. The 2nd time it is easier b/c I have already done it once. Eventually it becomes a habit to say no & I don't think about it much anymore. The same can be true for submitting. It takes practice to become good at it! It takes an active decision to decide to be submissive when I am called to be submissive by God. Some times I am not & I need to speak up or do something bold. The key is knowing what God's Word says about these different situations so I know when to submit & when not to submit.
    posted by LeeAnn
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 12:24 am
  7. Wow! Thanks ladies for so many good comments and testimonies -- how encouraging!

    Jody -- good word!

    Starr -- I hope many women will read your testimony:

    "There are two words that God has used to help me more than any others. Respect: it builds our men up for their leadership role; And Submission: which gives them the opportunity to lead. When I learned how to show respect to him and for his position as my "head", and I stepped under him in submission, he blossomed. These are the best years of our marriage."

    -- AWESOME!!

    Thanks Leslie and Vivian -- wise counsel!

    Molly! I'm so glad to hear this from a YOUNG woman! I love what you're writing on your blog site - keep it up! I hope you'll hop over to the Lies Young Women Believe site:
    http://www.liesyoungwomenbelieve.com/
    and share some of it with them!

    LeeAnn -- this principle is SO TRUE! In fact, what you're referring to is the slavery principle we find in Romans 6 -- thanks for sharing!

    I love hearing from all you True Women. It is so encouraging!
    posted by Kimberly Wagner
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 11:02 am
  8. I'm wondering what the starting point is in a marriage where the husband does not lead. I would like a leader who is in charge, but my husband doesn't seem to be interested (I've been at this 21 years). I know I am the Type A person and he is definitely Type B, so maybe it's too much for me to ask. The problem for me is that I don't really respect him. He does his own thing, and I do everything else in the home and for my family. I want to honor God, and we are both believers, but as far as roles, I don't know how anything would ever get done around the house if I didn't do them.
    posted by Barb
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 11:48 am
  9. Barb,

    I could've written your comment myself 15 years ago -- because it was the perfect description of my situation.

    Although my husband was a believer (even a pastor!) he was not providing leadership in our home. What I so desperately wanted and needed was for him to step into the role God had created him to fill, but what I didn't even realize was how my treatment of him affected his desire to lead. I don't know whether this could be your situation, I just know how I really affected my husband negatively and this seems to be a common occurrence with couples.

    We were trapped in a vicious cycle:
    I didn't treat him with respect because I resented his lack of leadership and taking of responsibility.
    He lacked the desire to lead and even felt intimidated by me. He didn't want to take on his responsibilities or perform any tasks for fear of my negative and critical reaction.

    Nancy DeMoss shared some of my testimony in a Revive Our Hearts Radio series you might find helpful. The link below will take you to the day where she is reading my testimony, but you also might want to listen to (or read the transcripts of) the entire series.

    http://www.reviveourhearts.com/radio/roh/today.php?pid=10073

    As I write this to you, I'm smiling as I look back to where we once were and rejoicing over the amazing work God has done in our lives and marriage. I would've never dreamed that it could be this good.

    God is able to do more than you can ask or think.
    Let me also encourage you to consider doing a couple things that might help you in your approach to your marriage:

    * The 30-Day Husband Encouragement Challenge (available on the Revive Our Hearts website)

    * The 40-Day True Woman Heart Preparation Devotional (available as a free download in the "True Woman Event Kit" -- on the True Woman site - see our Home Page)

    Barb, I pray that God will step into your marriage with His transformational power in ways that will amaze others and glorify Himself!
    posted by Kimberly Wagner
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 1:11 pm
  10. What do you think about the use of birth control when a young christian couple are settling in? Should birth control never be used? Should we just allow God to bless us with children whenever he sees fit? What if we have 18 kids like that family in Arkansas? How would we afford them all? Do you have any recommended reading for this topic? Thanks
    posted by Curious
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 1:13 pm
  11. Great question, Curious!

    I have a couple resources to recommend to you:

    http://www.reviveourhearts.com/topics/series.php?series=40&topic_name=Parenting

    If you go to this site you will find some great radio programs on this issue.

    Also, Holly Elliff has written an excellent booklet on this topic, "Turning the Tide: Having More Children Who Follow Christ"

    You can order this booklet through the Revive Our Hearts website store.

    If you have Nancy DeMoss' book "Lies Women Believe" I would encourage you to read chapter 7 "Lies About Children."

    And finally, what is most important is that you go to God on this issue. Seek Him through studying His Word and spending time in prayer asking Him to reveal His will to you on this issue. Don't be afraid to find out what He thinks about this issue. He is faithful. His ways are good.

    And by the way, I am living proof that some women who leave the size of their family in God's hands -- don't end up with 18!

    I have 2 living children, one with the Lord and I wanted more -- but this is how many God chose to bless us with. He knows best. And who knows -- He may one day lead us to adopt 18, but for now I'm content with what He's given :-)

    I pray He resolves this issue in your heart. Enjoy seeking Him!
    posted by Kimberly Wagner
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 1:50 pm
  12. I can relate to Barb. I feel like I'm always the one putting a fire under my husband to do things. I don't want to do that, but I have too...or nothing gets done. And as far as him being the spiritual leader, I don't even see him open his Bible or pray for us. Maybe he does when we aren't looking. I have no idea. I'm the one spiritually rearing our children. He does pray with the kids. One time I mentioned this to a friend of mine and she basically told me to expect less of him. It's so frustrating. We are in the process of trying to adopt. I'm starting to think that I don't know God at all because I felt like this was the path He wanted us to go down. But my husband has been sitting on paperwork for 4 months. He hates it, so he won't do it. Unfortunately, its holding up our whole adoption process. I'm sick of nagging him to do it...so I just left it. And there it sits. The only time he has worked on it is when I've guilted him into it. I don't like that. Can't he just do things because he knows that it will make me happy? Or better yet, because God wants him too? I always feel like its up to us women to make the marriages work. And it so maddening to me because shouldn't men care about their marriage too? Is it not important to them? I know my heart is not right in this and I'm coming from a place of bitterness...but bear with my honesty here, because I feel like its a sad thing that women are the ones that always have to bear these burdens and what do men care? Doing a 30 day encouragement for your husband is just another example to me of what I need to do...what about one for him to encourage me? Where are all those books and resources? I don't see those flying off the shelves...
    posted by MB
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 5:01 pm
  13. MB,

    Thank you so much for your honesty. I can relate to much of what you're saying. I remember living with a man much like what you've described -- I'm so thankful for the husband I have now. Not that I've been married more than once, no -- my husband is just a different man now, and he says I'm a different wife.

    Please follow through with my recommendations to Barb. I was amazed at the changes I saw take place in my marriage after I consistently worked on changing my heart and my treatment of my husband.

    And there is hope -- those books for men that you refer to may not be "flying off the shelves" as you say :-) but I'm encouraged about the number of men who are picking up copies of the "Love Dare" book and attempting to follow through on the content.

    Are there any couples in your church that are exhibiting godliness in their lives and enjoyment of one another in their marriage? If so, you might consider inviting them over for some "fellowship" time and perhaps a relationship could develop that might have an impact on your marriage.

    I will be praying that God begins a transforming work in your marriage.
    posted by Kimberly Wagner
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 5:33 pm
  14. I have to admit, I was pretty angry about this post. I didn't want to even listen to this radio program thing you suggested. I still am on the border about encouraging my husband :). However, I did feel like I learned something about God through the link you presented. And while I can't change my husband...I can ask God to help me change. I don't feel like I think I'm super spiritual. I've told my husband many times how I fight feeling condemned about my faith on a daily basis. I don't think my husband is a bad person. I just wish it wasn't always up to me to change things around. Have I worn away at my husbands masculinity? Most likely. I too have been depressed about our marriage, our kids, the stresses in our lives. It's hard to me to look at being a helpmate to him when I feel so down too. It just seems like I'm supposed to be everything to him and to fix things too. And then I read statements like some of the comments on the other blogs about not bothering your husband or being some kind of slave and being there to serve his needs 24/7 so he doesn't get upset. And it makes me feel like I can't rely on him for anything either because you should walk on eggshells so you don't irritate him. I don't understand submission and I honestly don't think the Bible says to walk on pins and needles around your husband either. I can work on my reactions and thoughts about my husband with the Lord's help, but I am not about to become some sort of slave who doesn't ask her husband for an opinion. I value what my husband says and if that is a problem, then I might as well have no talking in my marriage either. Maybe I misread some things about what others said...and I certainly have not listened to every resource on this topic on this website. This stuff just makes me feel all the more condemned as a wife and that its all my fault for the way our marriage has turned out. I guess I'm just destined to live under condemnation and the weight of both of our sins and hope God gives us better days....if only I will put forth the effort in asking Him to forgive me....I'd like to say I am set free, but I don't feel it today.
    posted by MB
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 6:32 pm
  15. http://www.desiringgod.org/ResourceLibrary/TasteAndSee/ByDate/2009/3927_Johns_Crazy_Joy_More_on_Bridegrooms_and_Purification/

    A good one for husbands by John Piper.
    posted by Michelle
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 7:03 pm
  16. MB,

    I want to comment on this statement from you:

    "And then I read statements . . . about not bothering your husband or being some kind of slave and being there to serve his needs 24/7 so he doesn't get upset. And it makes me feel like I can't rely on him . . . because you should walk on eggshells so you don't irritate him. I don't understand submission and I honestly don't think the Bible says to walk on pins and needles around your husband either."

    What you've just described is NOT biblical submission. God's design and plan is for marriage to a complementary harmony and union between husbands and wives.

    He created man first and gave specific responsibilities to him before woman ever appeared on the scene. And yet, although God designed man as the leader and gave him the responsibility of headship, this in no way implies that he occupies a superior position in relation to the woman.

    John Piper describes the leadership role of man in this way:

    “The call to leadership is not a call to exalt ourselves over any woman. It is not a call to domineer, or belittle or put woman in her place. The call to leadership is a call to humble oneself and take the responsibility to be a servant-leader in ways that are appropriate to every different relationship to women.”

    You cannot “fix” your husband, and you may not be able to change your marriage, but here are a few things that have helped in my relationship with my husband:

    1) Recognize that God is sovereign – appeal to Him to open your husband's eyes and help him to see that he is not fulfilling his role as the leader for your family (Prov. 21:1).

    2) Recognize that you are responsible to respond in godliness, humility and grace – even when sinned against (1 Peter 2:11-3:6).

    3) Search your own heart to see if there are areas of sin that need to be confessed before God and perhaps to your husband (Matt. 7:5).

    4) Consider writing out your concerns in a letter. Most men do not respond well to emotional pleas, angry confrontations or impassioned exchanges. Putting things in a cordial written form is sometimes helpful in preventing that type of confrontation.

    5) Focus on the fact that our time here is limited, and although difficult, time here is to be spent with an eternal perspective (2 Corinthians 4:16-18).

    6) Realize that your husband's faults or sins do not justify your sins of the flesh (Galatians 2:20, 5:16-26; 1 Corinthians 10:31; Romans 12:1).

    7) If your husband is a fellow-believer and is practicing the sin of slothfulness, it is your responsibility to humbly appeal to him and graciously confront him concerning his ungodly lifestyle with the goal being his spiritual restoration (Proverbs 27:5-6; Matthew 18:15-20; Galatians 6:1-3).

    I pray that you will witness God's transforming power at work in your own heart and in your marital situation as you humbly appeal to our Lord, as you seek the direction of the Spirit, and as you apply the truths of His Word to your life.
    posted by Kimberly Wagner
    on Wednesday, May 27, 2009 at 7:21 pm
  17. Thank you Kimberly. That helps.
    posted by MB
    on Thursday, May 28, 2009 at 10:55 am
  18. Kindly separate Biblical submission from the very strange Ms. Doyle's notion of "surrendering". That woman's advice is weird, extra-Biblical, unnecessary, passive-aggressive, and even condescending to men-all the while robbing a woman of her natural marital roles. I would NOT compare this at all to Biblical submission.
    posted by Jennifer
    on Saturday, May 30, 2009 at 4:20 pm
  19. I just stumbled across this blog so these comments above are almost a year old but wanted to add something anyway in case someone else is new and comes across it like I did. I am a very educated, independent business owner with a strong personality. I manage and run things daily. As I came to know Christ and SLOWLY became convicted that my heart desired a Christian marriage, submission was foreign to me. Over time, what began as a challenge of wills and pride became a source of comfort and relief. With God's help, I realized that I could still be "me" but only a "better me" while respecting and submitting to my husband. It took a while for both of us to "get it" right and we fail at it almost daily in some ways. But we both just begin again. My husband has the huge responsibility of making wise decisions for us (and of course, I never let him feel like he is out on a limb on his own, he always has me there for support and counsel) but ultimately, when I see for myself that his decision making (when we are at odds, which is rare) is made with his best intentions for us both, then I trust him more and more. And if I feel uneasy about his decision (I mean after all, even though I submit to his leadership, doesn't mean I can't still feel like I know better most of the time :-), then I put my trust in the Lord that the Lord will guide my husband. But like I said earlier, it is rare that we are at odds with major decisions. Our home is more peaceful. I NEVER, EVER feel like a "slave" or "servant" although I get great joy out of serving him. And he serves me as well. What does that look like in our home? I make him breakfast every morning and keep the house neat. He keeps gas in the car for me and fixes the toilet when I am out of town. Or I make him a fabulous dinner or he brings home take-out when I work late. I will actually TELL him how I appreciate his hard work. He will tell me how much he appreciated me getting up and fixing his lunch in the morning. It is constant service back and forth and the security I feel by having him lead our home makes me more loving as I manage our home. I may manage the daily home life, but he is the leader and we never lose sight of that. And the more I allow him to lead by respecting his role, the more loving and serving he becomes to my needs. It is a win-win situation and the best thing of all? I still get to be "me." The last time I looked, I don't remember seeing "doormat" written on the back of my shirt...I think is just said, "Happy Christian Wife." We definitely have our issues and arguments just like anyone else, but they are deflated much more quickly because we both try to remember: he serves me and I respect him. So there isn't a lot of room for huge blow-outs. We are far, far from the ideal couple, believe me. I can still be very short with him and he can still be thoughtless. But the point is, when we are less than wonderful to each other, we both get back on the right path again and just start over - in the right direction.

    Hope this helps someone out there.
    E
    posted by E
    on Saturday, April 10, 2010 at 12:13 pm
  20. Submission is becoming one with God and not about giving control or authority to others. It's also not about knocking yourself down. It's about respect. It's about submitting yourself to Godly plans and being true to yourself; being the person God wants you to be using your talents and such.
    Unfortunately, people think submission is giving the man control or about sex and it's not. Thanks for telling us submission is about God. I wished many boys/men would read this article. :)
    posted by Anonymous
    on Saturday, June 26, 2010 at 12:56 am

Leave a Comment:

We love hearing from you, and will post your comment as long as it is appropriate, and is written in a tone that is encouraging, edifying, and loving to others. Even then, know that the following comments do not necessarily reflect the views of Revive Our Hearts.